Are you supposed to press the Y-button to rebound your own missed shot when close to the basket for a tip-in? Sometimes the X-button works for me but I frequently get called for a foul if the opposing player gets the ball first. Often my player is obscured in the crowded paint so I can't determine who actually has the ball. I do get tip-ins by pressing the Y-button when I play with a friend but I have problems playing solo.
Mods please move this to the main section since this not mod related.